---
title: "A naming comment from an AI reviewer: rename it or let it go? | Proofline"
description: "Rename when the name states something the code no longer does, or breaks a convention the project writes down or enforces with a linter."
url: https://proofline.sh/learn/ai-review-naming-comment/
---

[Learning center](/learn/)

# A naming comment from an AI reviewer: rename it or let it go?

Rename when the name states something the code no longer does, or breaks a convention the project writes down or enforces with a linter. When the comment rests only on taste, decline it in one line that names the convention you follow, and spend no more time on it.

Code review The Proofline team November 22, 2026 4 min read

## Sort the claim before you weigh it

Naming comments from AI reviewers arrive in the same polite wording whether they matter or not. "Consider a more descriptive name" can mean three different things:

| The comment says, in effect | Evidence to look for | Decision |
| --- | --- | --- |
| The name describes behavior the code no longer has | The function body, its callers and the tests at your head commit | Rename, with its callers, in this pull request |
| The name breaks a project convention | A style guide the project adopts, a lint rule enabled in its configuration, or the names in the same module | Rename if the convention is written or enforced; otherwise treat it as taste |
| The reviewer would have picked another name | Nothing beyond the reviewer's preference | Decline in one line, citing the convention you follow |

The first row is about correctness, since a false name misleads the next reader the way a stale comment does. The second is a question of fact about the repository. Only the third is taste, and it is the most common.

## A name that now describes old behavior

In November 2026, a pull request in the OpenROAD project changed how its ITF reader treats keywords it cannot model. Before, the reader failed on them. After, it warns and continues. gemini-code-assist commented on the helper that does this: "The function `refuse` has been modified to issue warnings instead of failing (refusing) the execution." It continued, "Keeping the name `refuse` is misleading for future maintainers," and suggested a name "like `warnUnsupported` to accurately reflect its behavior." [Review comment](https://github.com/The-OpenROAD-Project/OpenROAD/pull/12189#discussion_r4516622229)

The claim checks out against the merged code. In `src/fsv/src/Itf.cpp` at the merge commit, the function is still declared `void refuse(...)`, and its body now calls `warn_` for each keyword it finds:

```
  // Keywords the reader cannot model yet.
  void refuse(const std::vector<const char*>& keys)
  {
    for (const char* key : keys) {
      for (const Node* n : takeAll(key)) {
        warn_(n->line,
              std::string(key) + " in " + label() + " is not supported");
      }
    }
  }
```

[Merged file](https://github.com/The-OpenROAD-Project/OpenROAD/blob/c256313/src/fsv/src/Itf.cpp)

The same pull request renamed a test from `RefusesAndChecksResistanceForms` to `WarnsOnUnmodeledAndChecksResistanceForms`, so the author did treat "refuses" as the wrong word in one place. The thread has no reply, and the pull request merged on 11 November 2026 with the function's old name. Callers still read `b.refuse(kRefusedConductor)`, which says the reader rejects those keywords. This was a comment that deserved a change: a rename of one helper method and its two calls, all in one file.

## A name that collides with a built-in

A different kind of naming claim appeared in GoogleCloudSamples/client-library-samples the same month. gemini-code-assist recommended renaming a parameter `id` to `build_id` "to avoid shadowing Python's built-in `id()` function." [Review](https://github.com/GoogleCloudSamples/client-library-samples/pull/173#pullrequestreview-5810566365)

That reason has a rule behind it, but the rule is opt-in. Ruff's A002 checks "for function arguments that use the same names as builtins", because readers "may mistake the argument for the builtin and vice versa." [Ruff source for A002](https://github.com/astral-sh/ruff/blob/main/crates/ruff_linter/src/rules/flake8_builtins/rules/builtin_argument_shadowing.rs) It is not in Ruff's default rule set, and I found no Ruff or flake8 configuration at the repository root at the merge commit. So this was a reasonable suggestion without a project convention behind it, and either answer would have been defensible. The author renamed the parameter. That rename missed one use of the old name, which [the guide to suggested fixes that change behavior](/learn/ai-review-suggestion-adds-bug/) follows to its result. Whichever way you decide a rename, search for every use before you commit it.

## Check the convention the project actually uses

Before you answer a convention claim, look in this order:

1.  The project's contributing guide or style guide, if it names one.
2.  The linter configuration in the repository: which naming rules are enabled, and which are deliberately off.
3.  The surrounding module. PEP 8 puts it plainly: "Consistency within a project is more important. Consistency within one module or function is the most important." [PEP 8](https://peps.python.org/pep-0008/#a-foolish-consistency-is-the-hobgoblin-of-little-minds)
4.  The language's own guidance. Go's review guidance says "Variable names in Go should be short rather than long," and "the further from its declaration that a name is used, the more descriptive the name must be." [Go Code Review Comments](https://go.dev/wiki/CodeReviewComments#variable-names)

A reviewer asking to rename a loop index `i` to `sliceIndex` in Go is arguing against the language's written guidance, and the reply can say so. If a rule your linter already enforces is behind the comment, CI decides it, as described in [findings already covered by lint](/learn/review-findings-already-covered-by-lint/).

## Dismiss taste in one line

A taste-only comment needs a short, specific reason, because the next reader of the thread should not have to reconstruct it. For example:

```
Keeping `ctx`: it matches every other handler in this package.
```

```
Not renaming: the field name mirrors the API's `build.id`, which callers search for.
```

Do not argue the merits of the alternative name. If the same suggestion recurs across pull requests and the team agrees with it, write the convention down or enable the lint rule, so the reviewer and CI enforce it on every commit. If the team disagrees, tell the reviewer in its instructions which naming rules the project follows.

## One month of free code review.

New organizations get one calendar month of hosted code review for private and public GitHub repositories. No card or cloud connection required. [Eligibility and fair-use terms](/free-code-review/).

[Start free with GitHub](https://proofline.sh/orgs/plan?offer=free_month)

## Related reading

-   ### [How to catch a suggested fix that would add a bug](/learn/ai-review-suggestion-adds-bug/)
    
    Code review The Proofline team November 22, 2026 4 min read
    
-   ### [Which review findings does your linter already cover?](/learn/review-findings-already-covered-by-lint/)
    
    Code review The Proofline team November 20, 2026 3 min read
